Reduce, reuse, reload: As Texas Tech Recycling Plant ceases operations, new solutions emerge

By Reece Nations

Image obtained from Ashley Rogers, Texas Tech Office of Communications & Marketing.

LUBBOCK – Once a bustling hub of activity committed to sustainability practices, Texas Tech’s on-campus center for recycling is now indefinitely closed.

When the recycling plant shuttered its operations over the summer as a cost-cutting procedure, many patrons assumed it would only be temporary. Sean Duggan, managing director of University Student Housing, said the decision to close the plant indefinitely was made after the profitability of recycled materials plummeted in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.
“For the whole fall last year, we were not receiving any money for the commodities that we were recycling,” Duggan said. “So, we were spending money taking load after load cardboard to be recycled, and we weren’t receiving any money for it. The next step was having to pay to have the items recycled.”
Over the past 11 years of its existence, Tech’s on-campus plant alone was responsible for recycling almost 450 tons of material, he said. The problem was the operation itself cost roughly half a million dollars annually to run. The plant’s profits only covered about 10% of its expenses.
All of the plant’s profits were in turn used to fund housing scholarships for students on campus, a program that will now have to siphon money from elsewhere in order to continue.
“And so, while I’m very proud of the work that we did, we can no longer justify the expense at this time,” Duggan said. “It just wasn’t something that we could continue right now due to all the economics involved.”
The on-campus facility was notable for accepting items other recycling operations in town would not. Styrofoam, glass and cardboard were all taken and sorted by the plant; items that the City of Lubbock’s satellite recycling locations do not accept. When the city’s industrial glass pulverizer broke in 2012, city council considered the machine too costly to fix at the time, according to the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal. While Tech’s plant helped with this issue to an extent, private recycling services are now all that is left to pick up the slack city-wide. Due to the city’s limitations when it comes to properly disposing of glass, services like Good EarthRecycling are commissioned to cover the cost of shipping the material out of town. Nick Nowicki, owner of Good Earth Recycling, said while his company’s services may not the most cost-effective from a business perspective, the Lubbock community has demonstrated a clear need for them.

Image obtained from Ashley Rogers, Texas Tech Office of Communications & Marketing.

I grew up in Dallas and recycling there was easy,” Nowicki, a Texas Tech alumnus from the class of 2018, said. “And so, I’ve always said, ‘Well, it’d be great if the city put us out of business one day and they just made recycling super easy for everybody.’”

Good Earth Recycling is a curbside recycling service that operates in both Lubbock and Ransom Canyon.
A monthly service fee is charged for collecting and transporting recyclable material on either a bi-monthly or weekly basis, according to the company’s website. Prior to the plant’s closing, Good Earth would deliver the material they collected to the on-campus facility, Nowicki said. Since then, the company has pivoted to operating its own plant for sorting and distribution.

“That was a big challenge because we had to figure out how many people that you have to have on staff, and you’ve got to figure out the best way logistically to transport everything — once you’ve got it sorted— to the different recyclers,” he said. “We also had to figure out how to best recycle material that (the city) wouldn’t take. For example, Styrofoam.”

Residents can drop off approved recyclable materials to any of the 10 locations city-wide, according to the City of Lubbock. While each of these locations accepts plastic types one and two, aluminum, tin, newspaper and office paper, only four of the “Citizen’s Convenience Stations” deployed by the city will take cardboard. Currently, recycling has been suspended in all on-campus student housing.

Recycling center signage noting its closure. Photo by Reece Nations.

Despite this, Carey Hewett, Director for Services and Campus Sustainability Officer, said custodial services still gather recyclable material from the educational and office buildings on Tech’s campus to be recycled with the city. Further, hospitality services make use of a large-scale cardboard compactor located behind the Student Union Building to assist in the university’s sustainability efforts, Hewett said.

This practice, combined with the campus’ other sustainability initiatives, earned Tech a bronze rating from the STARS Report.

The “Sustainability Tracking, Assessment & Rating System,” or STARS Report, is a performance rating issued by the Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. The report is based on metrics that gauge an institution’s commitment to sustainability practices.

“I think it just goes to show the cumulative effort of the many things that are going on around campus,” Hewett said. There’s a lot of emphasis on sustainability for the campus. It’s important to Texas Tech, and I think it’s important to students, too.”

About Reece Nations, Managing Editor